Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Welcome to Benny Casanova's!

Benny Casanova's cooks up Square Pies and delicious heroes from our NYC kitchen and delivers to your door. We're known for the crispy, crunchy crust of our pizza and toasty Brooklyn style parmesan sandwiches. Created by Top Chef Master, and Brooklyn native Franklin Becker. Just like Momma made in Palermo!

Order Online!

Place an order for Square Pie (not your ordinary Sicilian pizza) and Arancini Balls! We deliver throughout upper Manhattan. 

Order Now!
a close up of a sandwich on a plate



View Menu
a close up of food on a plate



Inquire Now

a close up of a sign

About Benny Casanova's | Square Pie | Arancini Balls

Our Story